Deontology versus Virtue Ethics

Virtue ethics is “concerned with Being rather than Doing,” It is “agent-centred rather than act-centred.” Critics maintained that it was unable to provide action guidance and hence, rather than being a normative rival to utilitarian and deontological ethics, it could claim to be no more than a valuable supplement to them.

Immanuel Kant, in his duty-based ethics emphasizes on doing the duty for the sake of duty, which is also the stand of all other deontologists in general. For example, if a wife falls sick, it is obviously the duty of her husband to take care of her. Duty-based ethics does not give any motivation other than duty.

Virtue ethics offer us virtues like loyalty, compassion, love and the like as motivations to do one’s duty in an effective way. Good virtues motivate us to do our duties.

Sometimes the duty-based ethics goes against common sense. For example, during the war time thousands and thousands of innocents like women and children are brutally killed by the army. But army men follow the duty-based ethics, so they simply kill the innocent in order to execute their plan that which is part of duty as army men.

Virtue ethics, however, has inspired many thinkers to give the right place to principles without making them absolute. As William Frankena notes rightly, “principles without traits [virtues] are impotent and traits without principles are blind.”

Related Posts

The crisis of ethical values in modern times is traced to a narrow perception of the good life.

QUES . The crisis of ethical values in modern times is traced to a narrow perception of the good life. Discuss. UPSC 2017 G S MAINS PAPER…

Mission Karmyogi : enhance capacity building of Indian Civil Servants and improve governance

QUES . “The objective of Mission Karmyogi is to enhance capacity building of Indian Civil Servants and improve governance. Discuss. HINTS: Mission Karmyogi is an ambitious initiative…

Citizens charters in India have not succeeded in their objectives of making the administrative system citizen-centric

QUES . Citizens charters in India have not succeeded in their objectives of making the administrative system citizen-centric. Do you agree? Give reasons. HINTS: Citizen’s Charter is…

Effective implementation of policies depends on the ethical values of Public Servants

QUES . In India, for the upliftment of the majority of people, governmental intervention remains a central fact of life. Nevertheless, the effective implementation of policies depends…

Ethical concepts of Thomas Hobbes

In his classic book Leviathan named after the gigantic monster mentioned in the book of Genesis and which was his image of the all powerful state, Hobbes…

Environmental Ethics

Environmental ethics is a new sub-discipline of philosophy that deals with the ethical problems surrounding environmental protection. It aims to provide ethical justification and moral motivation for…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!